Latest News

Sacramento DA / Media / Press Release Archives / 2016 Press Release Archives / 3.10.16: Couple Convicted for Felony Vehicle Insurance Fraud

Couple Convicted for Felony Vehicle Insurance Fraud

DATE:  March 10, 2016

CASE:  Harold Tietz & Deborah Tietz

PROSECUTOR:  Deputy District Attorney Kelly Mulcahy, Insurance Fraud Unit

Fifty-two-year-old Harold Tietz and 60-year-old Deborah Tietz were convicted by jury of three counts of felony insurance fraud.

The defendants purchased a Honda in Stockton.  At the time of purchase, they traded in their daughter’s PT Cruiser.  They received the trade in value, but still owed $9,100 on the PT Cruiser.  That remaining balance was rolled into the loan for the Honda, bringing the loan to approximately $37,000.  The Honda was fully insured and the Tietzs purchased GAP insurance.

A few months later, the Honda was found fully engulfed in flames in a rural part of San Joaquin County.  Approximately 30 minutes prior to the discovery, Harold called 911 to report his Honda stolen.  The Tietzs’ cell phone records revealed they never left their residence during the weekend of the theft, forcing Mercury Insurance to pay their claim.  Mercury Insurance paid off their lender and the GAP waiver covered the entire balance left on the loan.  Mercury Insurance then referred the case to the Department of Insurance for investigation. 

Further investigation into the Tietz’s use of their cell phones and home phone showed they were in communication with their daughters and son-in-law the night before and the morning the Honda was set on fire.  Their daughters and son-in-law were in the area the Honda was found burning during those calls.   Other evidence showed that the Tietzs had possession of the last key used to start the Honda to move it to the burn site. 

The defendants face a sentence of 7 years in prison.  Sentencing is set for April 8, 2016, at 1:30 p.m. in Department 33 before the Honorable Michael Savage.


Click here for PDF version

Copyright 2016 - All Rights Reserved by Sacramento District Attorney's Office.
California Relay Service 800.735.2929 TDD | Alternate Formats & Accessibility Policy | Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use